Houses for Rent in Lake County, IN. 119 Rentals Available. $1,300 2 Beds 2112 New York Ave. 2112 New York Ave 2112 New York Ave, Whiting, IN 46394 ... Lake County, Indiana. Located on the South Shore of Lake Michigan, Lake County contains everything from flat coastal areas to rolling hills. A short drive south from Chicago, this is a popular. Currently, there are 12 houses for rent available in Lake County, IN with rents starting from $590. Whether looking to lease a luxury house with panoramic views, a spacious single-family home or a cozy residence in a pet-friendly community, you can use our advanced search tools to find the home that best caters to your needs.